Today, I was seized with a wonderful idea that I had to act upon immediately. I'd been pondering nostalgia as a factor in food appreciation over the weekend. This morning, I wondered if Spaghettios and Hostess products -- specifically Twinkies, CupCakes, HoHos, and Ding Dongs -- were as good as I remember. So I ditched work and headed out to buy all of the above.
I had no idea where to buy these things in the grocery store. I found the Spaghettios in the pasta aisle. For some reason, it didn't occur to me to look there. I was wandering around the canned food aisles. Also, I didn't think to look for the Hostess products in the bread aisle. They just don't seem bread-like to me at all. However, they're only sold in big boxes because American corporations hate single people, so I had to go to a convenience store to get singles.
I'm sorry to say I fought and lost an internal battle with Pointless Food Snobbery at the convenience store. I wandered the aisles until I found the Twinkies, HoHos, etc. Then, I waited until the aisle was empty of customers before grabbing one of each. I refused to wait in line with those things in my hands, as if the guy buying a Jumbo Slurpee and one of those dubious convenience store ham sandwiches and the woman with the Doritos and Big Red were going to judge me. Nevertheless, I hid until the other customers were gone, peering above stacks of candy bars and motor oil to watch the progress of the line. I went up to the register and resisted an urge to explain to "Ester" that this was an experiment in food nostalgia. Ester barely glanced at me or my Twinkies, and I felt vaguely ashamed.
Spaghettios
I loved these things as a kid, even the weird little spongy meatballs. Especially the weird little spongy meatballs. And I loved how the O's came in three sizes. Apparently, they start with some kind of noodle cylinder in the factory, and punch out holes in three different sizes so as not to waste any noodle. I don't know about you, but I find that fascinating.
I just now heated up the can. What the fuck???? It's SWEET. The sauce has even less tomato flavor than ketchup! Wait a minute... it tastes like condensed Campbells' Tomato Soup. Of course. Spaghettios are made by Campbells. And that explains the goddamn noodle process!
All right, I'm trying a meatball. Jesus Christ. What *is* that taste? Why on earth did the sponginess appeal to me as a kid?
I just rinsed one off in the sink, and it looks like a turd.
So much for nostalgia for Spaghettios. Now, dessert. Here's what happened:
HoHos
I was pleased to find that HoHos come three in a package. How unexpected! An odd number of items in a package! What I always found lovely about HoHos was that you could unroll them. A HoHo is a chocolate-coated chocolate roll cake with white cream filling. More specifically, it is a nasty piece of chocolate leather-coated chocolate roll cake with gritty sweet white grease in the middle. The problem is, the chocolate sponge cake, which is the best part of the HoHo, is very thin, so the nastiness of the chocolate leather and the sweet white grease are overwhelming.
Next.
Ding Dongs
Wait a fucking minute... HoHos, Ding Dongs, and CupCakes are the same goddamn thing, just in different shapes and proportions. Shit.
Actually, it turns out that shape and proportion *do* make a difference. A Ding Dong is a chocolate sponge cake in the form of a hocky puck, with a zot of sweet white grease in the middle. The puck is then coated with "chocolate". The chocolate sponge cake to sweet white grease ratio is much higher than that of the HoHo, so Ding Dongs are more tolerable. Also, maybe I had a bad HoHo, because the cream filling in the Ding Dong wasn't gritty (Hostess doubtless uses the same cream filling in everything). However, the weird chocolate leather coating is still actively unpleasant. I'm sure the manufacturer had to dick around with the chocolate coating so that it wouldn't melt too quickly during packaging, transport, etc., but that means it doesn't melt in your mouth. Which feels just wrong. You don't chew chocolate like gum!
CupCakes
By far the best, as it has the highest chocolate sponge cake to sweet white grease ratio. It does have a slab of that nasty non-melting "chocolate" on top, with a pointless swirly pattern of what must be sweet white wax. However, chewing the "chocolate" in slab form is somehow less unpleasant than chewing it in leather form.
While I'm not surprised that these things taste horrible to me as an adult, I'm a bit disappointed that the Nostalgia Factor is so low.
On to Twinkies.
My fingers got greasy when opening the package: a bad sign. My fingers got even greasier handling the damn Twinkie. Twinkies have a low sponge cake to sweet white grease ratio, so I didn't expect much when I bit off half of one. I had to spit it out. The sweetness and greasiness were overwhelming. It occurred to me that the flavor of chocolate can mask a great deal. Twinkies, being made of yellow sponge cake, have nothing to mask their disturbing chemical taste. It was as if they're not made of flour or other edible ingredients, but with petroleum products. However, the sheer nastiness of the Twinkie posed an interesting challenge. I wasn't about to give up. I had 1.50 Twinkies left. I decided to freeze the other half of the one I bit, and deep fry the other one. I'd heard of deep fried Twinkies, a horrifying concept, but what the fuck. I decided to try it.
The frozen Twinkie was somehow not as bad as the raw Twinkie. It's not that the cold numbed my tongue; rather, hardening the sweet white grease turned it to a kind of nougat candy, and I just like the texture of frozen cake.
Now, for the other Twinkie. I whipped up some tempura batter and heated some oil. I rolled the hapless Twinkie in the batter, and dropped it into the hot oil with some trepidation, worried that it might fall apart or something. It bubbled satisfactorily, and a pleasant aroma wafted up. When it was golden brown, I lifted it out with tongs and placed it on a rack. I tapped the tempura coating -- hmm, nice and crisp.
It. Was. Fucken. Good. The tempura batter fused with the greasy yellow sponge cake and transformed it into a feather-light lattice with a cakey interior. An important lesson learned here: *hot* greasiness is good while *cold* greasiness is disgusting. Best of all, the sweet white grease transformed into... MELTED MARSHMALLOW GOODNESS!!!
So, while the Nostalgia Factor rates disappointingly low for all the things I tried today, I discovered that Twinkies make a fine raw material.