Replicant-Hiromi
Let me say this up front: don't read this blog if you want pretty stories. Or neat and tidy ones, or uplifting ones, or even dignified ones. I'm no ersatz starlet traipsing in and out of treatment centers. Recovery is both incredibly mundane and full of ugly humanity.
There was something about Blade Runner that I never understood until I picked up a copy of Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? recently and leafed through it. Now all the animal-related questions make sense -- Leon being asked about the turtle being flipped on its back, Rachael being asked about the wasp on her arm and the killing jar. Replicants aren't capable of animal-empathy. They may say the right things, but their eyes say different. The Voight-Kampff machine exposes the ways that their bodies betray their attempts to "pass." Even if you've mastered the proper gestures, gait, body language, and speech, your body can betray you on a deeper level.
Same goes for us and our real-life Voight-Kampff machines. Consider the following reading I've been doing about the brain. This NY Times article is about a prune-sized area of the brain called the insula, which essentially combines rational thinking with feelings and emotion. The article was written after it was reported that people who experience lesions to this part of the brain were able to quit smoking instantaneously. Here's a quote from the article:
The human insula, with its souped-up anatomy, is also important for processing events that have yet to happen, Dr. Paulus said. “When you decide to go outside on a cold day, your body gets ready before you hit the cold air,” he said. “It starts pumping blood to where you need it and adjusts your metabolism. Your insula tells you what it will feel like before you step outside.”The same goes for drug addicts. When an addict is confronted with sights, sounds, smells, situations or other stimuli associated with drug use, the insula is activated before using the drug. “If you give cocaine to an addict, you are affecting their brain’s reward system, but this is not what drives the person to keep using cocaine,” Dr. Paulus said. The craving is what gets people to use.
More on the brain chemistry of we addicts from this NY Times Sunday Magazine article:
Recent studies in both animals and humans have indicated that those with low levels of dopamine D2 receptors, which regulate the release of dopamine in the brain, are more likely to find the experience of taking drugs pleasurable. Some researchers, like Volkow, suggest that people with fewer D2 receptors experience a less intense reward signal, causing them to overindulge in order to feel satisfied.
and thees:
GABA (gamma-aminobutyric acid) is the brain's major inhibitory transmitter, and its role, in essence, is to keep glutamate, the main excitatory transmitter, from overwhelming us. In the extreme, too much glutamate can cause a seizure and too much GABA can put us in a coma. Researchers are particularly interested in the brain's critical balance of GABA and glutamate — some hypothesize that addictive craving is the result of too much glutamate or too little GABA ... "What's been shown is that people with alcohol and cocaine problems have less GABA in their brains, and we do know that medications that increase GABA have shown some efficacy in treating addiction." ([Dr.] Vocci says that it isn't yet clear whether the absence of GABA is a cause of addiction or a result.)
So if you were to show me an ice cold shot of vodka, my insula would betray me, as would distinctive differences in dopamine receptors and GABA activity in my brain. My brain is distinctive for other reasons, too. I've included two links about brain changes associated with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD): this one from a website, but if you are interested in medical journals, here's an article from the Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences. According to those articles, rape and eight years of psychological torment have rendered my medial prefrontal cortex smaller than normal and hyporesponsive; my amygdala hypersensitive; and my hippocampus diminished in volume, neuronal integrity, and functional integrity. In addition to brain changes, I have lower levels of cortisol and higher levels of epinephrine and norepinephrine, apparently. Having typed all that, I realize that the terror that I felt when the ex emailed me about joint taxes last week, the feeling that he was "going to get me" wasn't some figment separate from my tissue. So much for the mind-body dichotomy.
I used to believe that I was born broken. I believed I was raped and abused because in nature, that's the fate that befalls defective creatures -- if a newly-hatched chick has defects, the others will peck it to death. I don't believe that anymore. Or to be more honest, I'm maybe 90% sure that's not true. But I can't deny that my experiences have changed me so fundamentally that the changes are actually physical and measurable. I may not have been born broken, but I have been broken and warped.
Don't tell me I'm being harsh on myself -- there are things in me that are fundamentally wrong. Show a normal person ice cold vodka or vicodin, and they see liquid or white tablets. Show me, and my insula lights up, my pleasure centers go out of whack. What other twisted things make my brain light up, my pupils dilate? I spent a part of tonight gripped with intense self-loathing; that might not be abnormal, but how do you explain an almost overpowering urge to bite down on my own tongue so I can taste the blood? The inside of my head is not a pretty place. I don't look for pity or praise. What I need is an outlet. I feel that if I ride out the urges to drink and to self-harm, or if I give them concrete form external to me, I will purge them.
Some day, I will rule the world. I know it.
By the way, thanks, Syl, for listening. I'm looking forward to sleeping the long and healthy sleep of the just and deserving.
I've neglected this: 25peeps.com
Hiromi_X
Comments
Know that you inspire me.
And I don't say that because I want you to feel better I say it because it's the truth and I think you should know it.
1. Posted by Kalani on February 10, 2007
Life can be ugly. I appreciate the fact that you don't try to gloss over this. I've been in the mentally-defective ill state myself and it's ugly. I wish the world would just get a grip and accept that sometimes life is fucked up and our brains don't work "properly." I think more of us go through those periods at some point than not.
2. Posted by Nadia on February 10, 2007
I was reading an article recently about people who are doing research about "retraining" the brain in a way. This may not apply to serious addiction stuff or mental illness stuff--they weren't discussing some genetic or long-standing biological/chemical imbalance, but rather the imbalances that get created through learned experiences, pleasure receptors, and places like the insula. The basic thought was that if your brain can train itself to have a particular reaction to something, it can also un-train itself to do so. There was no definitive "answer" provided in the article, but in my own experience, I think this might possibly apply to trauma; I think I can say I feel my brain and its responses to certain stimuli are changing as I go through healing. It may also be true for some other old behaviors of mine that are connected to the assault in some way.
So I'd like to posit for now that while you and your brain are probably are most definitely changed, that perhaps "warped" isn't the most apt metaphor, because "warped" implies something that is more or less permanently bent out of shape, whereas the brain is not a static thing. It changed one way, it can, in time, and with practice, change another way (in some cases or to some extent, at least).
It also occurs to me that while yours and my changes might be more extreme and require more work to shift the shape of, EVERY human brain is changed through his/her life experiences. So I don't think we need to think of it as more "broken or warped" than any other person's brain developmental process. Our brains did what everyone else's brains did in the bigger picture--it's just the extremity of our experiences just ended up shaping our brains in a different way than others, is all. I don't see that shift as good or bad, but just there. (Note I say I don't see the *shift* as bad...I don't mean that some of the behaviors we've displayed as a result are necessarily healthy--but the brain is not judgmental in that way, it THINKS it is helping you when it does these things; but it's misfiring based on bad input from the outside, is how I see it.)
And certainly no thanks necessary. It's always a pleasure to knock oddly shaped brains with you. :)
3. Posted by Miss Syl on February 10, 2007
You're not being harsh on yourself. One of the reasons humans are supposedly on the top of the so-called food chain is our ability to adapt in a reasonably short time to adverse conditions. We typically think that part of that adaptation is emotional, but since emotion is chemically induced, it's all physical. We're all mutations based on our own experiences.
The only constant is change. You're becoming very strong, Hiromi, and it is a pleasure to read your words.
4. Posted by darkneuro on February 10, 2007
I'd say the rapists are the broken/defective ones (but then I'm mildly bipolar and mostly depressive.) When you're ruling the world, I'll be happy to say I knew you when. ;^)
5. Posted by tskathy58 on February 10, 2007
This wont do at all Hiromi. You see, I myself, have designs to rule the world someday..... designs that I will now have to egg-beater-proof.
Thanks for the heads-up, you're a good sport.
6. Posted by Onym on February 11, 2007
It's interesting- my wife takes a medication (I can't remember which one) that had the side effect of making her lose all desire to smoke. I wonder if they'll ever come up with a medication for addicts to take. I've heard of heroin addicts getting off by taking Ayahuasca. But, of course, the FDA is not going to approve that method. Also, out of curiosity, is there any interest in the harm reduction model of treatment down there in Texas? It's becoming quite common in Toronto, but I don't know anything about the states.
7. Posted by rufus on February 11, 2007
"There was something about Blade Runner that I never understood until I picked up a copy of Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? recently and leafed through it."
-I have referred to that story for years since seeing Blade Runner, so glad someone else is in on it now. :-) Also, the short story, Helen O'loy by Lester Del Rey as well as Twilight by John W. Campbell, must have been used as a an idea generators.
8. Posted by The Mad Scot on February 12, 2007
I'm glad you wrote this post! Blade Runner is one of my most favorite movies, and I've never read the book, despite that PKD is one of my favorite authors. I just assumed that the movie and the book were too different. So now I will read it, and watch it again.
9. Posted by SheenV on February 13, 2007
Hi Hiromi,
An interesting post, of course-- talking about other sci-fi shows that explore the adaptation of the brain, despite prior structural make-up, is Battlestar Galactica and the reactions of the various Cylon characters-- Sharon in particular. It's interesting to watch the series, because basically Sharon's transformation to human is made of events that typically dramatically influence human brain structure (falling in love, having a baby, traumatic combat situations).
Good luck, as always.
Chuck
10. Posted by whatthechuck on February 18, 2007
Tried to access your article reference "an article from the of the New York Academy of Sciences". Each time I do the screen of my computer at the State University of New York at Stony Brook shuts off my access to the computer! Can I get a citation to access this article.
11. Posted by Gershom Orwell on July 25, 2007
Gershom, this is the article:
Amygdala, Medial Prefrontal Cortex, and Hippocampal Function in PTSD
LISA M. SHIN, SCOTT L. RAUCH, and ROGER K. PITMAN
Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences
Volume 1071 published July 2006, pp 67-79
12. Posted by Hiromi on July 25, 2007